Mosaic Neuberger

Shabbos Daf 06 - Carrying Through a Karmelis, Four Reshuyos

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
Mar 12, 2020
Length:
39 min 43 sec
Downloads:
93
Views:
1462
Comments:
2

Series: Daf Yomi

Venue: Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere

Gemara:

References: Shabbat: 6a Shabbat: 6b 

More from this:
      Comments
      2 comments
      Leave a Comment
      Title:
      Comment:
      Anonymous: 
      1. Title: The Hidden Scroll of Issi ben Yehuda
        Author: Avi Garson ,

        Hi Rabbi, Lemaskana, Issi ben Yehuda's view is that one of the Avot Melachot doesn't warrant the punishment of stoning. A Peleh. The Gemara takes the message in this hidden scroll seriously to the extent that it is willing to say the Beraita contains additional words because of this opinion... The question that must be raised is why doesn't the Gemara examine this incredible teaching in great detail? Which Melacha is it referring to and what is the source behind this exception? Why doesn't Rav scrutinise the teaching found in this mysterious scroll?Are there any Mefarshim who delve into this? Thank you...

      2. Title: The Hidden Scroll of Issi ben Yehuda
        Author: Avi Garson ,

        Hi Rabbi, Lemaskana, Issi ben Yehuda's view is that one of the Avot Melachot doesn't warrant the punishment of stoning. A Peleh. The Gemara takes the message in this hidden scroll seriously to the extent that it is willing to say the Beraita contains additional words because of this opinion... The question that must be raised is why doesn't the Gemara examine this incredible teaching in great detail? Which Melacha is it referring to and what is the source behind this exception? Why doesn't Rav scrutinise the teaching found in this mysterious scroll?Are there any Mefarshim who delve into this? Thank you...

      Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Miriam and Alan Goldberg and family to mark the yahrzeit of Samuel Goldberg, R’ Shmuel Meir ben R’ Eliyahu Ha Cohen Z”L and for a mazel tov to SALT Rebbe, David and Brigitte Silverberg upon their Lag BaOmer wedding anniversary