Kaddish: All for 1 for 1 for All?

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
Sep 4, 2019
Length:
47 min 3 sec
Downloads:
6
Views:
29
Comments:
3

Machshava:

References: Megilla: 21b 

Description

"Observations of a Minyaner Mourner" part 1 EVERYONE saying Kaddish together- Preferable, Tolerable or Terribly Problematic?

Additional Materials

More from this:
Comments
3 comments
Leave a Comment
Title:
Comment:
Anonymous: 
  1. Title: KADDISH
    Author: IRWIN NIEDOBER ,

    RABBI GRUNSTEIN , THANK YOU FOR ANOTHER INFORMATIVE SHIUR. HAVING RECENTLY COMPLETED THE 11 MONTHS FOR MY MOTHER I FEEL THERE SHOULD BE A SHIUR ON THE DECORUM OF THE CONGREGANTS WHILE AVEILIM ARE SAYING KADDISH. I AM SURE YOU ARE AWARE OF THE LACK THEREOF. IN RESPONSE TO YOUR QUESTION OF MULTIPLE PEOPLE SAYING KADDISH I FOCUS ON THE PERSON CLOSEST TO ME WHEN I RESPOND AMEN ETC. I WOULD LIKE TO WISH YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY A HAPPY HEALTHY AND MEANINGFUL YEAR. IRWIN

    1. Title: Re- Your kind feedback
      Yehoshua GrunsteinIRWIN NIEDOBER, 

      Hi Irwin and good morning,

      As always, many thanks for your feedback, which both gives motivation to continue to be teach, as well as gives ideas for the future.

      Wanted to wish a long-life as you finish your year of mourning for your mother z"l, and hope that you will be able to continue her legacy in this world. I myself am now in my 7 month of the 11, and thus can well understand and will address the lack of decorum in shul in general, and during Kaddish [as well as מי שברך's, אנעים זמירות and more] during the year as I experienced it as well.

      Indeed, tomorrow [Wednesday] will address who you should be answering Amen to if multiple people say Kaddish at once, with both the advantages and disadvantages to it.

      Wishing the ENTIRE family a Shana tova in every way and endeavor, and many thanks again,

      Yehoshua

  2. Title: KADDISH
    Author: IRWIN NIEDOBER ,

    RABBI GRUNSTEIN , THANK YOU FOR ANOTHER INFORMATIVE SHIUR. HAVING RECENTLY COMPLETED THE 11 MONTHS FOR MY MOTHER I FEEL THERE SHOULD BE A SHIUR ON THE DECORUM OF THE CONGREGANTS WHILE AVEILIM ARE SAYING KADDISH. I AM SURE YOU ARE AWARE OF THE LACK THEREOF. IN RESPONSE TO YOUR QUESTION OF MULTIPLE PEOPLE SAYING KADDISH I FOCUS ON THE PERSON CLOSEST TO ME WHEN I RESPOND AMEN ETC. I WOULD LIKE TO WISH YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY A HAPPY HEALTHY AND MEANINGFUL YEAR. IRWIN

Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Gedaliah Jaffe in loving memory of his father, Marshall Jaffe, Moshe Mendel ben Shneur Zalmen a"h and by Howard M Weintraub l'zecher nishmat Mindel bas Zvi Mordechai on her yahrtzeit and by Judy & Mark Frankel, Rachelle & Joseph Etra, Yonatan & Michal Frankel and Yair & Miriam Frankel to mark the yahrtzeit of their son and brother Moshe Yehuda z"l ben Meir Eliyahu and by the Cohen, Kraut and Silver families in memory of Walter Silver z"l, עובדיה בן צבי יצחק ושרה פייגא ז״ל and for a refuah shleimah for Rivka Chana bas Sarah Leah and by Sheila and Ronny Apfel and family in memory of their beloved Mr. Willy Apfel a"h, לעילוי נשמת רב זאב בן עזריאל