Rebbe, if I understood him, said that a Messiah candidate who dies proves thereby that he was not the true Messiah. But what about if WE murder the Messiah claimant (such as the gentiles claim that we did to Jesus, and which a censored gemoro confirms)? Does that prove that he was not the Messiah?

Rebbe, if I understood him, said that a Messiah candidate who dies proves thereby that he was not the true Messiah. But what about if WE murder the Messiah claimant (such as the gentiles claim that we did to Jesus, and which a censored gemoro confirms)? Does that prove that he was not the Messiah?