- Rabbi Zvi Sobolofsky
- Date:
-
Series:
BCBM
Venue: Cong. Bnai Yeshurun (Teaneck, NJ)
Gemara: - Duration: 27 min
Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
4 comments Leave a Comment
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Jeffrey Gross #44;
Rabbi Why can’t we diffenetiate and say that there should be no concern re peiros hanoshrim by something done by a goy that a Jew uses, since it seems to be two steps removed from me doing the actual milacha. Can one argue that the logical extension of me benefiting from the goy’s action would be me asking the goy to do it directly, not me doing the milacha myself? Jeff Gross
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Jeffrey Gross #44;
Rabbi Why can’t we diffenetiate and say that there should be no concern re peiros hanoshrim by something done by a goy that a Jew uses, since it seems to be two steps removed from me doing the actual milacha. Can one argue that the logical extension of me benefiting from the goy’s action would be me asking the goy to do it directly, not me doing the milacha myself? Jeff Gross
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Teacher Reply #44;
Definitely a valid svara but Tosfos and the Rashba did equate them Sent from my iPhone > On Dec 13, 2018, at 10:06 AM, [email protected] wrote: > > Dear Rabbi Zvi Sobolofsky, > > A question has been posted for you on YUTorah by Jeffrey Gross. > > Jeffrey Gross asked this question treated as [public] message. > > Please click here to reply publicly (your response will be visible on the website, and your email address will remain invisible) or click here to reply privately (your message will be sent directly to the questioner, and your email address will be visible to that person only). > > Shiur Title: ×"â¬× Malachos â Shiur 8 ק×צר (harvesting) part 3 > Subject: Peiros Noshrim > Question: Rabbi Why canât we diffenetiate and say that there should be no concern re peiros hanoshrim by something done by a goy that a Jew uses, since it seems to be two steps removed from me doing the actual milacha. Can one argue that the logical extension of me benefiting from the goyâs action would be me asking the goy to do it directly, not me doing the milacha myself? Jeff Gross
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Teacher Reply #44;
Definitely a valid svara but Tosfos and the Rashba did equate them Sent from my iPhone > On Dec 13, 2018, at 10:06 AM, [email protected] wrote: > > Dear Rabbi Zvi Sobolofsky, > > A question has been posted for you on YUTorah by Jeffrey Gross. > > Jeffrey Gross asked this question treated as [public] message. > > Please click here to reply publicly (your response will be visible on the website, and your email address will remain invisible) or click here to reply privately (your message will be sent directly to the questioner, and your email address will be visible to that person only). > > Shiur Title: ×"â¬× Malachos â Shiur 8 ק×צר (harvesting) part 3 > Subject: Peiros Noshrim > Question: Rabbi Why canât we diffenetiate and say that there should be no concern re peiros hanoshrim by something done by a goy that a Jew uses, since it seems to be two steps removed from me doing the actual milacha. Can one argue that the logical extension of me benefiting from the goyâs action would be me asking the goy to do it directly, not me doing the milacha myself? Jeff Gross