- Rabbi Zvi Sobolofsky
- Date:
-
Series:
Daily Shiur
Venue: YU Wilf Campus
Gemara: - Duration: 13 min
Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
A full discussion of the halacha lemaaseh of psik reisha d'lo nicha leh/ one derabanan/ two derabanans/ the Rama's psak about cutting cake
3 comments Leave a Comment
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Jeffrey Gross #44;
Rabbi, Is it possible that the Rama only allows a psik resha with a double dirabanan in the case of trapping the flies since both dirabanan's are due to a deficit in the actual milacha (a fly that is not usually trapped and a large box). The case of the Noda Biyihudah regarding cutting letters of a cake, however, has one deficit in the actual milacha (lo al minas lichtov), but the shinoy relates more to the gavra. Could that be why the Rama is machmir in the second case? (Perhaps the Rama would be similarly machmir and not allow closing a small box on the flies with a shinoy?) Thanks Jeff Gross
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Jeffrey Gross #44;
Rabbi, Is it possible that the Rama only allows a psik resha with a double dirabanan in the case of trapping the flies since both dirabanan's are due to a deficit in the actual milacha (a fly that is not usually trapped and a large box). The case of the Noda Biyihudah regarding cutting letters of a cake, however, has one deficit in the actual milacha (lo al minas lichtov), but the shinoy relates more to the gavra. Could that be why the Rama is machmir in the second case? (Perhaps the Rama would be similarly machmir and not allow closing a small box on the flies with a shinoy?) Thanks Jeff Gross
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Jeffrey Gross #44;
Rabbi, Is it possible that the Rama only allows a psik resha with a double dirabanan in the case of trapping the flies since both dirabanan's are due to a deficit in the actual milacha (a fly that is not usually trapped and a large box). The case of the Noda Biyihudah regarding cutting letters of a cake, however, has one deficit in the actual milacha (lo al minas lichtov), but the shinoy relates more to the gavra. Could that be why the Rama is machmir in the second case? (Perhaps the Rama would be similarly machmir and not allow closing a small box on the flies with a shinoy?) Thanks Jeff Gross