Kesuvos Daf 42 - Knas After Gmar Din

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
March 16 2015
Length:
40min 10s
Downloads:
51
Views:
1008
Comments:
2

Series: Daf Yomi

Venue: Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere

Gemara:
Ketuvot 

Collections: Rabbi Lebowitz: Daf Yomi Kesubos

References: Ketuvot: 42a ,  Ketuvot: 42b  

    More from this:
    Comments
    2 comments     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 
    1. Title: splitting reisha and seifa
      Author: Larry Eisenberg
      Reply
      In the mishna on 41B there was an issue with the reisha not being consistent with R Shimon, yet R Shimon only being cited as arguing on the seifa. One answer given is that originally the two halves may not have been taught together, with R Yehuda later compiling them into one mishna, so R Shimon didn't see the reisha to argue against it. Following this logic, why don't we use the same answer whenever the Gemara is stuck trying to figure out the author of a mishna given that often a Tanna's opinion will only work with half of the mishna. Let us just say that the two halves were not originally together, and so could be the work of two different Tannaim.
    2. Title: splitting reisha and seifa
      Author: Larry Eisenberg
      Reply
      In the mishna on 41B there was an issue with the reisha not being consistent with R Shimon, yet R Shimon only being cited as arguing on the seifa. One answer given is that originally the two halves may not have been taught together, with R Yehuda later compiling them into one mishna, so R Shimon didn't see the reisha to argue against it. Following this logic, why don't we use the same answer whenever the Gemara is stuck trying to figure out the author of a mishna given that often a Tanna's opinion will only work with half of the mishna. Let us just say that the two halves were not originally together, and so could be the work of two different Tannaim.

    Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Debbie Nossbaum in loving memory of her father, Nathan Werdiger, נתן בן שלמה אלימלך and by Harris and Elli Teitz Goldstein l'ilui nishmas Elli's beloved father, הרה'ג רב פינחס מרדכי טייץ, on his 30th yahrzeit on ד' טבת and in loving memory of Dr. Felix Glaubach, אפרים פישל בן ברוך, to mark his first yahrtzeit, by Miriam, his children, grandchildren & great grandchildren