Description
We will complete our analysis of the controversy regarding Smichus Geula LeTefilla shel Arvis and the order of Tefilla and Shema in the evening. Are we dealing with GeUla & Tefilla as two separate entities, a Matif and a Nitar, or are we integrating GeUla & Tefilla into one unit of Kabbalas Ol Malchus Shamayim based on the verse 'Yeraucha im shemesh'? Based on these two definitions we will explain the two-fold Machlokes (Svara & Krah) between R' Yochanan & R' Yehoshua, and the opinion of Rav Amram Gaon that we must recite a Kadish at night between GeUla & Tefilla. The Gaon accepts R' Yeshua regarding integration, but accepts R' Yochanan re: Matir & Nitar. In shachris there is no possibility of kadish because of the Kiyum Kabalas Shamayim.
0 comments Leave a Comment