Berachos Daf 21 - Birchas Hatorah and Birchas Hamazon Min Hatorah

Speaker:
Ask speaker
Date:
August 22 2012
Length:
44min 31s
Downloads:
211
Views:
2108
Comments:
3

Series: Daf Yomi

Venue: Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere Beis Haknesses of North Woodmere

Gemara:
Berachot 

Collections: Rabbi Lebowitz: Daf Yomi Berachos

References: Berachot: 21a ,  Berachot: 21b  

    More from this:
    Comments
    3 comments     Leave a Comment
    Title:
    Comment:
    Anonymous: 
    1. Title: berachos 21 - why don't geirim say birkas hamazon
      Author: Yitz Rosenthal
      Reply

      Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???

    2. Title: berachos 21 - why don't geirim say birkas hamazon
      Author: Yitz Rosenthal
      Reply

      Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???

    3. Title: berachos 21 - why don't geirim say birkas hamazon
      Author: Yitz Rosenthal
      Reply

      Hi. At the beginning of the shiur you mentioned Rav Soloveitchiks reason citing his father as to Tosfasos' reason as to why women, kohanim and leviim DO in fact say birkas hamazon - i.e. since the "mechayev" of birkas hamazon is being in the category of 'al shehinchalta laAvoseinu' - and women, kohanim and leviim do have a yerusha so to speak from the avos. If so, according to this, why do geirim have to say birkas hamazon??? Are geirim patur from birkas hamazon according to Tosafos???