Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
- Downloads:
- 0
- Views:
- 724
- Comments:
- 0
One gets a different impression from Tosafot (Shabbat 99b, s.v. oh). There, the Talmud inquires as to the liability of one who throws an object onto a (10x4) pillar from a reshut ha-rabbim. Perhaps, since it passed through a m’kom p’tur, the thrower is exempt. Tosafot, quoting Rabbeinu Tam, explain that the scenario is such that the object paused in the m’kom p’tur, interrupting the original koach. The implication is that the potential exemption stems from the interruption; had the “koach” led right into a “koach kocho” there would have been liability.
The Rashash, however, notes based on Sanhedrin 77b that such a process would actually be called “kocho”. The intent of Tosafot, then, was not to address the issue of kocho or koach kocho, but to note that the “koach” would be considered to have emanated from the m’kom p’tur only if the item paused there. (See also R. Shlomo Fisher’s Beit Yishai, 78, for a lengthy analysis of this topic, and also Resp. Eretz Tzvi, I, 112.)
Gemara:
Collections: Rabbi Feldman Mini Shiur (Daf)
References: Shabbat: 99b
Publication:
Mini Shiur (Daf) Volume 1
-
Shevii of Vayigash: Yosef Saves the Egyptian Economy
- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Parsha:
- Duration: 33 min
-
Honoring Grandparents- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Parsha:
-
Daf Yomi and Chanukah: Tadir- Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman
- Date:
-
Machshava:
- Duration: 34 min
-
How SALTY must the Challa be?- Rabbi Yehoshua Grunstein
- Date:
- Duration: 9 min
-
שמחת חתן וכלה, שיעור ב׳ [זלזול בכבוד חכמים, שמחו״כ כבין אדם למקום, ביטול ת״ת לכלה ולמת] | Kesubos shiur #30
- Rabbi Tanchum Cohen
- Date:
-
Series:
Daily Shiur
Venue: YU High School for Boys
Gemara:Halacha:History:Machshava:Personalities: - Duration: 1 hr 3 min
-
At the Intersection of Astronomy, Lomdus and Le-ma'aseh: Bein ha-Shemashos finale | Hilchos Milah #8 [Yoreh Deah 262:4-7, 266:8-9]- Rabbi Tanchum Cohen
- Date:
-
Venue:
Cong. Beth Abraham (Bergenfield, NJ)
Halacha:Machshava:Personalities: - Duration: 46 min
-
The Halacha of the Extraordinary: From Supernatural Oil, To Miraculous People and Lab Cultivated Meat- Rabbi Shay Schachter
- Date:
-
Venue:
Stern College
Halacha: - Duration: 44 min
-
Hashem Leans In [Yeshiva Masmidim Chanukka Tisch]- Rabbi Tanchum Cohen
- Date:
-
Venue:
Cong. Beth Abraham (Bergenfield, NJ)
Gemara:Halacha:History:Machshava:Parsha:Personalities: - Duration: 17 min
0 comments Leave a Comment