Description
We seek to answer the question of Tos' in Masechet Shabbat 75a: Can one be חייב for a מלאכת קלקול in the case of חובל according to Rebby Shimon, and yet require that the חבלה be a מלאכה הצריכה לגופא? In order to answer this question we will study the Mishna on 93b with Rashi and Tos'. The debate revolves around the following issue: why does R' Shimon require a מלאכה הצריכה לגופא? Is it because of the Halachic principle of Meleches Machsheves? Or is it because of the requirement of דומיה דמשכן? The difference will be חובל according to R' Shimon.
0 comments Leave a Comment