Description
This shiur is dedicated to the approach of the Ramban to the sugya of a mistake in the Beracha. Acording to the Ramban, the Safek of the Gemara revolves around the following scenario: he completed his Beracha properly, i.e. with the correct Nusach, and then added a wrong Nusach as a retraction of the correct one he had completed. We will analyze the principle of תוך כדי דיבור כדיבור דמי, a general rule that allows a person to retract his statement very soon after he made the statement, e.g. in testimony and monetary transactions. How does this apply to Berachot? Our sugya vacillates on this issue.
0 comments Leave a Comment