- Rabbi Hershel Schachter
- Date:
-
Venue:
Yeshiva of Central Queens
Gemara: - Duration: 1 hr 41 min
Please click here to donate and sponsor Torah learning on YUTorah
3 comments Leave a Comment
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Moshe Blum #44;
בכבוד הרב שליט'א I was recently listening to the rov`s shiur about dina dmalchusa dina where he said that the reason we pay taxes today is not really due to dina dmalchusa dina, but more to do with a "din shutfas", and that by not paying taxes to the government it is as if I am stealing from every citizen. Does this mean therefore, that if I am over payed from the government- such as extra child tax benefits being paid by mistake, I have to return it, and can`t rely on "taos akum" being permitted as it is as if I am stealing from every citizen- including Jews? Thank you, Moshe Blum (London)
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Moshe Blum #44;
בכבוד הרב שליט'א I was recently listening to the rov`s shiur about dina dmalchusa dina where he said that the reason we pay taxes today is not really due to dina dmalchusa dina, but more to do with a "din shutfas", and that by not paying taxes to the government it is as if I am stealing from every citizen. Does this mean therefore, that if I am over payed from the government- such as extra child tax benefits being paid by mistake, I have to return it, and can`t rely on "taos akum" being permitted as it is as if I am stealing from every citizen- including Jews? Thank you, Moshe Blum (London)
Author: False == 1 ? Anonymous : Moshe Blum #44;
בכבוד הרב שליט'א I was recently listening to the rov`s shiur about dina dmalchusa dina where he said that the reason we pay taxes today is not really due to dina dmalchusa dina, but more to do with a "din shutfas", and that by not paying taxes to the government it is as if I am stealing from every citizen. Does this mean therefore, that if I am over payed from the government- such as extra child tax benefits being paid by mistake, I have to return it, and can`t rely on "taos akum" being permitted as it is as if I am stealing from every citizen- including Jews? Thank you, Moshe Blum (London)